By Robert Pius
For some unknown reason in recent Oscar history, the judgment on how good or bad a performance an individual actor gave seems to be tied up in the film's reception as a whole. In the past, it was quite common for an actor (especially in the supporting categories) to give a standout performance in a film that critics found less than stellar and still be able to achieve a nomination based on their work and not the movie as a whole. One could almost say that these performers had more difficult tasks than their peers in highly regarded films. It is likely that when you are acting with a good script, adept direction and added help from all the other below-the-line workers on a strong production, it is probably easier to do your best work. But what about those people who found themselves with rotten material or in films that were ripped apart to no one's liking in the editing room, but yet one actor somehow managed to rise above the problem and do outstanding work? Now that's a real achievement when you have to hold it together while everything else is falling apart around you. The recent release of "Hillbilly Elegy" has brought this topic to mind. Reviewers have been surprisingly hard on this film. While some esteemed critics like Janet Maslin and Richard Roeper have praised the film, others have seemed to delight in tearing it apart. Speculation has been that the film's malice comes more from a political bent than the actual film's quality. Director Ron Howard recently addressed this in an interview, saying because the film tells the story of a kid who grew up to be a political conservative, reviewers have disregarded the story of family dynamics he has presented and instead judged the film as if they were in the voting booth on November 3rd again. Glenn Close was thought to be a strong frontrunner to win an Oscar for her work here finally. Still, the negative reviews have sent her plummeting on prognosticators charts even though some of her reviews have been excellent. Even some of the film's most vitriolic reviews have begrudgingly admitted that her performance is quite good. Her poor early showing (or lack thereof) at the critic's groups has also brought about more doubt towards her awards campaign. So I ask you, "why has the academy adopted this all or nothing approach to acting nominations?" How many times have we heard the idea that someone just got swept into the nominations because they were in a Best Picture nominee? Did anyone really feel that Rachel McAdams was so outstanding in "Spotlight" that she merited to be one of the five best supporting actresses of that year, or was it just luck that she was the only woman in the Best Picture frontrunner and got swept into the nominations? Some would argue that Kim Basinger (a Best Supporting Actress winner that is often cited as not holding up well over time) got swept all the way to the Oscar podium by being the only woman in a Best Picture contending film in 1997 for "L.A. Confidential." I think this is a fascinating subject to ponder since there was a time when doing good work in a mediocre or even lousy film could still get you noticed. Heck, it could even get you a career! Morgan Freeman was a struggling actor for years with moderate success on Broadway and on a children's T.V. show on PBS called "The Electric Company." Suddenly, at the age of 50, he was cast in a film called "Street Smart." It came from a studio known for mostly producing shlock and starred Christopher Reeve, who was struggling to maintain his leading man status a decade after "Superman." The film came and went, but Freeman was noticed. He swept through the significant critic's group awards that year and received an Oscar nomination that then lead to steady and acclaimed work in films ever since. Charles Durning gave acclaimed performances in numerous films such as "Dog Day Afternoon" and "Tootsie," but his two Oscar nominations came from the mediocrely received Mel Brooks remake of the Jack Benny film "To Be or Not To Be" and most surprisingly for his role in "The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas." That film was based on a hit Broadway musical but was panned by critics who called the Burt Reynolds/Dolly Parton starring film a big bloated mess. However, Durning had a sensational moment as a singing and dancing politician who struts around with incredible joy and abandon. Seeing the usually serious Durning cut loose like that probably added to the appeal and he was remembered on Oscar morning, something I doubt would happen today. Best Supporting Actress though, is the category where in the 70s and 80s, it was almost the norm for someone from a less than raved about film to grab a nomination. Interestingly, Glenn Close is the inspiration for this piece. In 1984 three of the five Best Supporting Actress nominees came from films whose receptions ranged from disappointing to being an outright mess and Close herself was one of those nominees! It is also fascinating that "Amadeus," which swept thru that year's nominations with eleven and won eight of them, saw its third billed star and key supporting performer, Elizabeth Berridge, surprisingly left out of the Best Supporting Actress category. That would never happen today. A substantial role from a Best Picture nominee would never be blocked by three women whose films made critics wince a bit. Close was nominated for the third year in a row as Best Supporting Actress for a highly anticipated Robert Redford film, "The Natural." While not exactly a flop or universally panned, the film did not prove to be the awards juggernaut people thought it would be and it only received some below-the-line nominations and Close's nomination. While Close has joked that she was nominated more for how well she was lit, she actually is the heart of the film and gives a lovely and moving performance in an otherwise uneven film. Also nominated that year was Christine Lahti for "Swing Shift," which was a bit of a disaster except for her performance. Star Goldie Hawn and director Jonathan Demme disagreed vehemently on the final cut of the film and the version that was finally released (Hawn's) was pretty much panned. Lahti has said she heard her role would be cut or reduced at various times since she came off better than leading lady Hawn. Despite the turmoil, Lahti still got a nomination, helped by a win at the New York Film Critic's Circle Awards. The fifth nominee that year was Geraldine Page, for a very brief role in the less than stellar received "The Pope of Greenwich Village." Page is quite powerful in her brief scenes in an otherwise forgettable film. The list continues into the 70s. I defy anyone to sit through the Dustin Hoffman film "Who Is Harry Kellerman and Why Is He Saying Those Terrible Things About Me" and not leave feeling overwhelmed by the tedium of it all. Except that the excellent Barbara Harris shows up three-quarters of the way through the film and gives a luminous wry performance. It's a bit shocking that audiences stayed with the film long enough even to see her late arrival in the movie but this was back in the days before home screeners and academy members had to actually sit through the entire films, thus maybe voting for Harris out of the sheer relief that they hadn't wasted an entire evening. Nowadays, the screener would have been scrapped twenty minutes in. Probably the most fascinating Oscar inclusion in this vein is Brenda Vaccaro's 1975 Best Supporting Actress nomination for "Jacqueline Susann's Once is Not Enough." The film has a whopping 4.6 rating on IMDB and is a soapy wallow in trash from the author of "Valley of the Dolls." Critics were not kind at all but Vaccaro is appealing in the film. Due to heavy campaigning, she managed to get herself and Oscar nomination and actually win the Golden Globe for Best Supporting Actress, beating out practically the entire acclaimed female ensemble of Robert Altman's "Nashville." So it remains to be seen if the poor reviews for "Hillbilly Elegy" will sink Glenn Close's chance at a nomination or even an Oscar win. There already seems to be a growing sentiment that the reviews were unnecessarily harsh and based more on anti-Trump feelings than what was actually seen in the film. The audience reaction on Rotten Tomatoes has been quite positive and it should be noted that the film is playing well to many members of the Academy. They are not as plugged into the discourse on social media as we all are. Notably, some of the same sources that raved about the book when it came out (before Donald Trump was elected) are now trashing the same story and even saying it shouldn't have even been made. It will be interesting to see if, as in days gone by, a performance can rise above the reaction to the film it is in and still earn a nomination just on the actor's own individual contribution. Do you think Glenn Close can still get nominated for her performance in "Hillbilly Elegy?" What do you think her chances are of winning now? Let us know your thoughts in the comments section below or on our Twitter account. You can follow Robert and hear more of his thoughts on the Oscars and Film on Twitter at @robertpius_
Comments
|
BEST PICTURE Nomadland (37) - AFCC, AWFJ, BOFCA, BSFC, CCA, CFCA, CIC, DFCS, DFWFCA, GFCA, GG, GOTHAM, GWNYFCA, HFCS, IFCA, IFJA, IPA, KCFCC, LEJA, LFCC, LVFCS, NDFS, NSFC, NTFCA, OFCS, PFCS, PGA, SEFCA, SFBAFCC, SFCS, StLFCA, TFCA, TIFF, VENICE, VFCC, WAFCA, WFCC Promising Young Woman (10) - AACTA, COFCA, HCA, KCFCC, MCFCA, NFCS, OAFFC, SCA, SDFCS, WFCC Minari (7) - AFCA, NCFCA, NYFCO, OFCC, OFTA, PCC, UFCA Ma Rainey's Black Bottom (3) - BFCC, CIC, PFCC The Trial Of The Chicago 7 (3) - DFCS, HFCS, SAG Da 5 Bloods (2) - CIC, NBR First Cow (2) - FFCC, NYFCC Another Round - EFA Bad Boys For Life - NAACP Dwelling In The Fuchun Mountains - ICS Judas And The Black Messiah - AAFCA Rocks - BIFA Small Axe - LAFCA The United States vs. Billie Holiday - AARP BEST DIRECTOR Chloé Zhao (48) - AACTA, AFCC, AWFJ, BOFCA, BFCC, BSFC, CCA, CFCA, COFCA, DFCS, DFCS, DFWFCA, DGA, FFCC, GFCA, GG, GWNYFCA, HCA, HFCS, IFCA, IFJA, IPA, KCFCC, LAFCA, LEJA, LVFCS, MSFCA, NCFCA, NDFS, NSFC, NTFCA, NYFCC, NYFCO, OAFFC, OFCC, OFCS, OFTA, PCC, PFCC, PFCS, SEFCA, SDFCS, SFBAFCC, SFCS, StLFCA, TFCA, VFCC, WAFCA Regina King (3) - AAFCA, BFCC, UFCA Spike Lee (3) - CIC, HFCS, NBR Lee Isaac Chung - AFCA Emerald Fennell - NFCS Darius Marder - SCA Steve McQueen - LFCC Andrew Patterson - GOTHAM Gina Prince-Bythewood - NAACP Kelly Reichardt - ICS Aaron Sorkin - AARP Thomas Vinterberg - EFA Remi Weekes - BIFA BEST ACTRESS Carey Mulligan (26) - AACTA, AFCA, AFCC, CCA, COFCA, DFCS, DFWFCA, GFCA, HCA, HFCS, KCFCC, LAFCA, LEJA, MCFCA, NBR, NFCS, NTFCA, NYFCO, OAFFC, OFTA, PCC, PFCS, SCA, SDFCS, StLFCA, WFCC Frances McDormand (24) - AWFJ, BOFCA, CFCA, DFCS, FFCC, GWNYFCA, HFCS, IFCA, IFJA, IPA, LFCC, LVFCS, NCFCA, NDFS, NSFC, OFCC, OFCS, SEFCA, SFBAFCC, SFCS, TFCA, UFCA, VFCC, WAFCA Viola Davis (5) - BFCC, CIC, NAACP, PFCC, SAG Andra Day (2) - AAFCA, GG Sidney Flanigan (2) - BSFC, NYFCC Maria Bakalova - IPA Paula Beer - EFA Nicole Beharie - GOTHAM Sophia Loren - AARP Rosamund Pike - GG Wunmi Mosaku - BIFA Isabel Sandoval - ICS BEST ACTOR Chadwick Boseman (26) - AACTA, AAFCA, AWFJ, BFCC, CCA, CFCA, CIC, DFCS, DFWFCA, GG, IFCA, LAFCA, LEJA, LFCC, MSFCA, NAACP, OFTA, PCC, PFCS, SAG, SEFCA, SFBAFCC, StLFCA, VFCC, WAFCA, WFCC Riz Ahmed (21) - AFCA, AFCC, COFCA, GFCA, GOTHAM, GWNYFCA, HFCS, IPA, KCFCC, LVFCS, NBR, NDFS, NFCS, NYFCO, OAFFC, OFCC, SCA, SDFCS, SFCS, TFCA, UFCA Delroy Lindo (10) - BOFCA, DFCS, HCA, HFCS, IFJA, NCFCA, NSFC, NYFCC, OFCS, PFCC Anthony Hopkins (5) - AARP, BIFA, BSFC, FFCC, NFCS Sacha Baron Cohen (2) - GG, IPA Mads Mikkelsen - EFA Aditya Modak - ICS Steven Yeun - NTFCA BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS Youn Yuh-jung (32) - AFCA, AWFJ, BFCC, BSFC, COFCA, DFCS, GFCA, GWNYFCA, HCA, IFCA, KCFCC, LAFCA, LEJA, MCFCA, NBR, NCFCA, NTFCA, NYFCO, OAFFC, OFCC, OFTA, PCC, PFCS, SAG, SCA, SEFCA, SDFCS, SFBAFCC, SFCS, StLFCA, VFCC, WAFCA Maria Bakalova (16) - AFCC, BOFCA, CCA, CFCA, CIC, FFCC, HFCS, IFJA, LFCC, MCFCA, NDFS, NSFC, NYFCC, OFCS, TFCA, UFCA Amanda Seyfried (4) - DFWFCA, IPA, LVFCS, PFCC Ellen Burstyn (2) - DFCS, NYFCO Jodie Foster (2) - AARP, GG Kosar Ali - BIFA Sônia Braga - ICS Glenn Close - NFCS Olivia Colman - AACTA Olivia Cooke - HFCS Dominque Fishback - AAFCA Phylicia Rashad - NAACP BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR Paul Raci (18) - AFCC, BOFCA, BSFC, CFCA, COFCA, FFCC, GFCA, GWNYFCA, HCA, HFCS, IFCA, NBR, NSFC, OFCC, SCA, SDFCS, SFBAFCC, StLFCA Daniel Kaluuya (17) - AAFCA, AFCA, CCA, DFCS, DFWFCA, GG, LEJA, LVFCS, NFCS, OAFFC, OFTA, PCC, PFCS, SAG, SFCS, TFCA, VFCC Leslie Odom Jr. (9) - AWFJ, BFCC, HFCS, IFJA, KCFCC, NYFCO, OFCS, UFCA, WAFCA Sacha Baron Cohen (7) - AACTA, DFCS, MCFCA, NCFCA, NDFS, NTFCA, SEFCA Chadwick Boseman (5) - CIC, IPA, NAACP, NYFCC, PFCC Francisco Barreiro - ICS Demián Bichir - AARP D’angelou Osei Kissiedu - BIFA Shaun Parkes - LFCC Glynn Turman - LAFCA BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY Nomadland (20) - AFCA, AWFJ, CCA, CFCA, COFCA, DFCS, GFCA, GWNYFCA, HFCS, IFJA, KCFCC, LFCC, NCFCA, OAFFC, OFCC, OFCS, OFTA, SEFCA, USC, WAFCA One Night In Miami (6) - AAFCA, HCA, LEJA, LVFCS, PCC, PFCS The Father (5) - BIFA, IPA, NFCS, SCA, SDFCS I'm Thinking Of Ending Things (5) - BOFCA, BSFC, FFCC, StLFCA, UFCA First Cow (4) - DFCS, ICS, PFCC, SFBAFCC Ma Rainey's Black Bottom (2) - BFCC, CIC Borat Subsequent Moviefilm - WGA News Of The World - NBR BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY Promising Young Woman (23) - AFCC, AWFJ, CCA, CIC, COFCA, DFWFCA, GFCA, HCA, HFCS, IPA, KCFCC, LAFCA, NDFS, NFCS, NYFCO, OAFFC, OFCC, OFCS, OFTA, SFCS, StLFCA, WAFCA, WGA Minari (11) - AFCA, BFCC, DFCS, FFCC, LEJA, NBR, NCFCA, SDFCS, SEFCA, SFBAFCC, TFCA The Trial Of The Chicago 7 (10) - AACTA, AARP, CIC, DFCS, GG, HFCS, MCFCA, PFCS, UFCA, VFCC Never, Rarely, Sometimes, Always (7) - CFCA, GWNYFCA, IFJA, NSFC, NYFCC, OAFFC, WFCC The Forty-Year-Old-Version (2) - GOTHAM, NAACP Another Round - EFA Bacurau - ICS Fourteen - GOTHAM Judas And The Black Messiah - LVFCS BEST CINEMATOGRAPHY Nomadland (33) - AFCA, AFCC, AWFJ, BOFCA, BSFC, CCA, CFCA, CIC, COFCA, DFWFCA, GFCA, GWNYFCA, HCA, HFCS, LEJA, LVFCS, MCFCA, NBR, NCFCA, NDFS, NSFC, NYFCO, OAFFC, OFCS, OFTA, PFCC, PFCS, SDFCS, SEFCA, SFCS, StLFCA, UFCA, WAFCA Mank (4) - FFCC, IPA, OFCC, SCA Tenet (4) - BFCC, HFCS, NFCS, NTFCA Small Axe (2) - LAFCA, NYFCC Dwelling In The Fuchun Mountains - ICS First Cow - SFBAFCC Hidden Away - EFA I'm Thinking Of Ending Things - PCC Saint Maud - BIFA The Vast Of Night - KCFCC BEST COSTUME DESIGN Ma Rainey's Black Bottom (8) - BAFTA, CCA, CIC, HFCS, LVFCS, OFTA, PFCS, SFCS Emma. (3) - CFCA, LEJA, SDFCS The Personal History Of David Copperfield (2) - HCA, IPA Hidden Away - EFA Misbehaviour - BIFA BEST FILM EDITING Nomadland (10) - AFCA, AWFJ, BOFCA, GWNYFCA, LEJA, NDFS, OFCS, SFBAFCC, SFCS, StLFCA The Trial Of The Chicago 7 (9) - CCA, CIC, COFCA, HCA, HFCS, IPA, MCFCA, PFCS, UFCA Sound Of Metal (3) - CCA, LVFCS, OFTA The Father (2) - BIFA, LAFCA I'm Thinking Of Ending Things (2) - BSFC, CFCA The Invisible Man (2) - MCFCA, SDFCS Once More Unto The Breach - EFA Tenet - WAFCA The Wasteland - ICS BEST MAKEUP & HAIRSTYLING Ma Rainey's Black Bottom (6) - BAFTA, CCA, CIC, HCA, LEJA, MUAHS Birds Of Prey (2) - MUAHS, OFTA The Endless Trench - EFA Mank - HFCS Misbehaviour - BIFA Pinocchio - MUAHS BEST ORIGINAL SCORE Soul (30) - AFCA, AFCC, BOFCA, CCA, CFCA, CIC, COFCA, DFCS, FFCC, GFCA, GG, GWNYFCA, HCA, HFCS, HMMA, LAFCA, LEJA, LVFCS, NCFCA, OFCC, OFCS, OFTA, PCC, PFCS, SCL, SFBAFCC, SFCS, StLFCA, UFCA, WAFCA Tenet (4) - HMMA, IFJA, MCFCA, SCA Mank (3) - DFWFCA, HFCS, NDFS David Attenborough: A Life On Our Planet (2) - HMMA, IFMCA Minari (2) - BSFC, HMMA Berlin Alexanderplatz - EFA Blizzard Of Souls - SCL The Call Of The Wild - IFMCA Fukushima 50 - IFMCA The Invisible Man - HMMA The Midnight Sky - IPA News Of The World - HMMA Nomadland - IFCA The Personal History Of David Copperfield - IFMCA Preparations To Be Together For An Unknown Period Of Time - ICS Wolfwalkers - IFMCA Wonder Woman 1984 - IFMCA BEST ORIGINAL SONG One Night In Miami (11) - CCA, CIC, DFCS, GFCA, HFCS, HFCS, IFCA, LEJA, MCFCA, OFTA, PFCS The Life Ahead (3) - GG, HMMA, IPA Eurovision (2) - HCA, SCL Giving Voice - HMMA Judas And The Black Messiah - LVFCS The Outpost - HMMA Over The Moon - NDFS Trolls: World Tour - HMMA BEST PRODUCTION DESIGN Mank (22) - ADG, BAFTA, CCA, CFCA, CIC, FFCC, GFCA, HCA, HFCS, IPA, LAFCA, LVFCS, MCFCA, NDFS, NFCS, OFTA, PFCS, SDFCS, SDSA, SFCS, StLFCA, WAFCA Tenet (2) - ADG, SDSA Da 5 Bloods - ADG First Cow - SFBAFCC His House - BIFA Ma Rainey's Black Bottom - LEJA The Personal History Of David Copperfield - EFA Promising Young Woman - SDSA A Portuguesa - ICS Soul - ADG BEST SOUND Sound Of Metal (7) - BAFTA, DFCS, HFCS, ICS, IPA, LEJA, OFTA Little Girl - EFA The Reason I Jump - BIFA BEST VISUAL EFFECTS Tenet (12) - BAFTA, CCA, DFCS, HFCS, HFCS, IPA, NCFCA, NFCS, PFCS, SDFCS, SFCS, StLFCA The Invisible Man (6) - CFCA, CIC, HCA, LEJA, LVFCS, OFTA Mank - VES The Midnight Sky - VES Mulan - VES The One And Only Ivan - VES The Platform - EFA Possessor - FFCC Project Power - VES Soul - VES BEST ANIMATED FEATURE Soul (36) - AAFCA, AFCC, AWFJ, BFCC, CCA, CIC, DFCS, DFCS, DFWFCA, FFCC, GFCA, GG, HFCS, IFCA, IFJA, LEJA, LVFCS, MSFCA, NAACP, NBR, NCFCA, NDFS, NFCS, NTFCA, NYFCO, OFCC, OFCS, OFTA, PCC, PFCC, PFCS, PGA, SEFCA, SFBAFCC, StLFCA, WAFCA Wolfwalkers (15) - AFCA, BOFCA, CFCA, COFCA, GWNYFCA, HCA, IPA, KCFCC, LAFCA, NYFCC, OAFFC, SDFCS, SFCS, TFCA, UFCA Josep (2) - EFA, ICS The Wolf House - BSFC BEST INTERNATIONAL FEATURE FILM Another Round (17) - AFCC, AWFJ, CFCA, EFA, GFCA, IFJA, KCFCC, LFCC, LVFCS, MCFCA, NCFCA, PFCS, SEFCA, SFBAFCC, StLFCA, UFCA, WAFCA Minari (14) - AFCA, CCA, COFCA, DFCS, DFWFCA, GG, GWNYFCA, NTFCA, NYFCO, OFCS, OFTA, PCC, SFCS, VFCC La Llorona (6) - BSFC, HCA, IPA, LEJA, NBR, WFCC Bacurau (3) - BOFCA, NYFCC, TFCA Night Of The Kings (3) - AAFCA, BFCC, NAACP Collective (2) - AARP, NSFC The Life Ahead (2) - HFCS, SDFCS And Then We Danced - NDFS A Sun - HFCS Beanpole - LAFCA His House - CIC Identifying Features - GOTHAM Jumbo - PFCC Los Fuertes - FFCC Martin Eden - OFCC BEST DOCUMENTARY FEATURE Time (13) - AFCC, BFCC, DFWFCA, GFCA, GOTHAM, GWNYFCA, LAFCA, NBR, NYFCC, OFTA, PFCC, SDFCS, SEFCA Collective (10) - BSFC, CEHA, EFA, IPA, LFCC, OAFFC, SFBAFCC, StLFCA, TFCA, VFCC Dick Johnson Is Dead (9) - CCA, CFCA, COFCA, DFCS, IFCA, IFJA, NCFCA, OFCS, UFCA Boys State (8) - AFCA, CIC, DFCS, LVFCS, OFCC, PCC, PFCS, WAFCA All In: The Fight For Democracy (5) - AAFCA, AWFJ, HCA, NDFS, NTFCA The Dissident (2) - KCFCC, NFCS My Octopus Teacher (2) - HFCS, PGA The Painter And The Thief (2) - AWFJ, BOFCA Beastie Boys Story - HFCS Class Action Park - HCA Crip Camp - IDA The History of the Seattle Mariners: Supercut Edition - SFCS Mucho Amor - LEJA John Lewis: Good Trouble - NAACP The Reason I Jump - BIFA A Secret Love - AARP The Social Dilemma - MCFCA Stuntwomen: The Untold Holywood Story -WFCC A Thousand Cuts - GOTHAM The Way I See It - NYFCO The Year Of The Discovery - ICS You Don't Nomi - FFCC AuthorsNicole Ackman Archives
April 2021
Categories
All
|